Demand Gen

Sample data

November 17, 2026

•
Sample data

{{minute}}

min Read

Demand Gen vs Performance Max for B2B SaaS: Which Should You Run?

Waqas Kokhar

Founder at ScalixAI

On this page

What Is Centralized Notification Infrastructure?

The Default State: The Big Notification Mess

Building Workflows Without Engineering Dependency

Easy Debugging with Logs 

Embedded & Branded In-App Inbox

Multi-Tenant Aware Preference Center

Find out what your PMax campaign is really buying

Get My Google Ads Audit

Key takeaways

1.

Performance Max hunts the cheapest conversion, which in B2B means brand traffic.

2.

Demand Gen cannot touch search results, so its numbers stay more honest.

3.

Optimise PMax to CRM-qualified stages, never raw form fills or free signups.

4.

Audit PMax search terms; brand terms near the top mean resold demand.

5.

Run Search first, Demand Gen second, and Performance Max last, if ever.

For most B2B SaaS and AI companies, Demand Gen is the better choice than Performance Max. PMax is built to find the cheapest conversion anywhere on Google. In B2B lead gen, the cheapest conversions are usually branded searchers who were coming anyway, and form fills your sales team never calls back. Demand Gen runs only on YouTube, Shorts, Discover, and Gmail, so it can't borrow credit from your brand traffic.

We've run both. When we took over Fyxer's account, Performance Max was eating most of the budget and paid search was producing zero qualified pipeline. We switched PMax off. Twelve months later, Fyxer had grown to $30M ARR, Google Ads was driving 12% of company revenue, and Demand Gen had become the channel we used to grow demand once Search was maxed out.

This post is for founders and paid media teams deciding where the next Google Ads dollar goes, or trying to work out whether the PMax campaign already running is actually working.

Demand Gen vs Performance Max at a glance

[table]
| Performance Max | Demand Gen
Where ads run | Search, YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail, Maps (plus Shopping with a feed) | YouTube, Shorts, Discover, Gmail
Shows on search results? | Yes | No
Targeting | Audience signals are hints; Google decides who sees ads | You pick audiences per ad group: lookalikes, custom segments, remarketing
Creative control | Google mixes your assets and can auto-generate video | You choose video or image per ad group
Reporting | Channel and search terms reports, but one blended budget and bid | Ad group, audience, and asset level
What it finds in a typical B2B account | The cheapest conversion on any channel | New people who look like your best customers
Biggest B2B risk | Brand cannibalization and junk leads | Long, expensive learning phase
Best fit | E-commerce with a feed, or lead gen with qualified offline conversions | B2B SaaS that has maxed out Search and has video
[/table]

What is the difference between Demand Gen and Performance Max?

Performance Max is a single campaign that bids across every Google channel, including search results, toward one conversion goal. Demand Gen is a visual campaign for YouTube, Shorts, Discover, and Gmail, where you control the audiences and creative in each ad group.

That difference decides everything else. PMax optimises the whole Google inventory to hit your goal, so it will spend wherever that goal is cheapest to reach. Demand Gen can only reach people who are not searching right now, so every conversion it gets has to come from creating interest. One is a demand capture tool with some reach attached. The other is a demand creation tool.

1. Know why Performance Max struggles in B2B lead gen

PMax does exactly what you tell it to. The trouble is what most B2B accounts tell it.

If your primary conversion is a form fill, a free signup, or a "book a demo" click, PMax looks for the cheapest version of that action across all of Google. In a B2B SaaS account, there are two cheap pools:

  • People already searching for your brand. They convert at high rates and low cost because they were coming anyway.
  • Low-intent form fillers on Display, Discover, and Gmail. Students, job seekers, competitors, and accidental taps all count as conversions if the form accepts them.

This is what we found at Fyxer. The account was optimising for form fills, and PMax had learned to find form fillers, not buyers. Clicks went up. Pipeline didn't. Switching it off and moving budget into branded and problem-aware Search fixed the signal.

Does Performance Max cannibalize branded search?

Yes, it can. Google gives priority to a Search campaign only when the query matches one of your exact match keywords. Brand variants, misspellings, and "brand + feature" queries can go to PMax instead, and PMax then reports those conversions as its own.

This matters more in B2B than most people expect. For PAM AI, branded search drove 68% of active pipeline in the quarter we tracked through HubSpot. If a PMax campaign had been picking up even part of that brand traffic, it would have looked like the best campaign in the account while creating almost none of that demand.

The fix is campaign-level brand exclusions. Google says they also block misspellings and foreign-script versions of your brand, which negative keywords miss.

2. Know why Demand Gen fits B2B SaaS better

Demand Gen gives you the controls B2B accounts need: separate audiences, chosen creative, and clean exclusions. Because it never touches search results, its numbers aren't inflated by people who already know you. It's harder to make Demand Gen look good, and that's useful, because what you see is closer to the truth.

Fyxer shows how much control matters. The rebuilt Demand Gen programme produced 2,226 primary conversions at a £362 blended CPA, reaching £207 in its best month. It worked because we could see and act on each piece:

  • Separate audience pillars. Prospecting, lookalikes, and remarketing each had their own ad group. GB Lookalikes became the best ad group at £126 CPA. In PMax, that audience would have been one signal inside a blended asset group.
  • Creative we could cut. Video took 69% of spend and drove 90% of conversions at £280 CPA. Image ads ran at £1,070. Two image sets drew 178k clicks for 54 conversions. We could see that and move the budget. PMax decides the asset mix for you.
  • Exclusions everywhere. Existing paid users and predicted-zero-LTV signups were excluded from every ad group, so Google couldn't hit the target by re-converting people we already had.

The brand effect was visible, too. While Demand Gen was live, Fyxer's branded search impressions rose from a 62k monthly average to 169k (2.7x), and they fell below baseline after it stopped. Demand Gen created the searches. Search captured them. A PMax campaign would have bid on both ends and taken credit for the loop.

For format and placement details, see our Demand Gen and YouTube ads playbook.

3. Use Performance Max only when these conditions are true

PMax can work for B2B SaaS. We've seen it work, and we've seen far more accounts where it shouldn't have been running yet. Run it only if all of these are true:

  1. It optimises to a qualified stage, not a form fill. Import qualified leads or opportunities from your CRM with values attached. Google itself recommends connecting CRM data and optimising to conversions close to the final sale.
  2. Brand exclusions are on. Your brand terms are excluded at campaign level, and your brand campaign has the budget to cover all brand demand.
  3. You have conversion volume. Our rule of thumb is at least 30 qualified conversions a month before PMax gets a real budget. Below that, it falls back to whatever it can hit, which is usually the cheap stuff.
  4. Search is already maxed. You've covered every keyword worth bidding on and want extra reach, not a replacement for Search.
  5. You can prove lift. You run it as a Google uplift experiment or with a holdout, not as a campaign that "looks good" in the dashboard.

There's one real exception. A low-ACV, product-led tool where people pay by card at signup behaves more like e-commerce. A signup is close to revenue, so PMax's cheap-conversion hunting hurts less. Even then, keep brand exclusions on.

4. Audit the Performance Max campaign you're already running

If PMax is live in your account, run these five checks before you scale it or cut it. Each one tells you something different.

[table]
Check | Where to find it | What a bad result looks like
Brand share of search terms | PMax search terms report | Your brand name and variants in the top terms
Where the money went | Channel performance report | Most spend on Display or Discover with weak conversion quality
What it's optimising to | Conversion goals in campaign settings | Form fill, page view, or "all signups" as primary
Lead quality | CRM: sales-accepted rate of PMax leads vs Search leads | PMax leads accepted at a fraction of the Search rate
Real lift | Pause test or uplift experiment | Total conversions barely drop, and brand Search picks up the slack
[/table]

How to read the results:

  • Brand terms high, lead quality fine: PMax is mostly reselling your brand. Add brand exclusions and watch whether volume holds.
  • Brand terms low, lead quality poor: PMax is finding junk on visual inventory. Change the conversion goal before changing anything else.
  • Both fine, lift proven: keep it, and scale in steps no larger than 15% at a time.

Don't conclude PMax "works" because its CPA is lower than Search. If it's buying brand traffic, it should be cheaper.

5. Decide whether to run Demand Gen and PMax together

You can run both, but most B2B SaaS accounts shouldn't until each has proved itself alone. Both campaigns can serve on YouTube, Discover, and Gmail, so they reach overlapping audiences. When they run side by side, you lose the ability to say which one created a signup.

If you do run both:

  • Use the same exclusions in both: customers, zero-LTV signups, and brand terms.
  • Report on blended account CPA and CRM pipeline, not on each campaign's own conversions.
  • Change one campaign at a time. Fyxer's spring Demand Gen relaunch changed four things at once, and CPA hit £1,776. We never isolated the cause.

Our default order for B2B SaaS is Search first, Demand Gen once Search is saturated, and PMax last, if ever. Our Demand Gen vs Search guide covers the first step in that sequence.

6. Don't expect either one to reach a narrow buying committee

Neither Demand Gen nor PMax can target job titles or named accounts. If you sell to a small set of roles, such as security leaders at funded startups, LinkedIn is usually the better place to create demand.

Oneleet, a SOC 2 compliance platform, is a good example. We ran LinkedIn to cold ICP lists segmented by role and seniority, plus retargeting. That drove $1.63M in LinkedIn-influenced closed-won revenue across 150 deals (Oneleet LinkedIn Ads case study).

The measurement lesson applies to PMax, too. LinkedIn's own dashboard showed a 0.36x return. Multi-touch attribution in the CRM showed about 7x more revenue. LinkedIn undercounted. PMax tends to overcount because it can claim brand conversions. Either way, the platform's number is not the answer. Your CRM is.

Which should you run? A quick decision guide

[table]
Your situation | Run this
Search isn't covering all converting keywords yet | Neither. Scale Search first
Search is maxed, you have video and can fund learning | Demand Gen
Buyer is a narrow job title or account list | LinkedIn before either
Card-at-signup PLG tool with high conversion volume | PMax with brand exclusions, as an experiment
PMax already live and "performing" | Run the five-check audit before you scale it
Budget under 20x your target CPA per day | Neither. Demand Gen needs at least 20x target CPA to learn
[/table]

If you're still deciding whether video belongs in your mix at all, read if YouTube ads are worth it for B2B SaaS.

Find out what your PMax campaign is really buying

Most PMax campaigns we audit in B2B SaaS look strong on CPA and weak in the CRM. We'll pull your search terms, channel split, and conversion goals, match PMax leads to pipeline, and tell you whether to keep it, fix it, or move the budget to Demand Gen.

Get My Free Google Ads Audit

Comparing partners first? See our list of top Google Ads agencies in the US, the best B2B YouTube ads agencies, and our detailed ScalixAI review.

Frequently asked
‍questions

Is Performance Max good for B2B lead generation?

Only with the right setup. PMax needs a qualified conversion imported from your CRM, brand exclusions, and steady volume. Optimised to raw form fills, it tends to find cheap, low-quality leads and branded searchers.

Is Demand Gen better than Performance Max?

For most B2B SaaS companies, yes. Demand Gen gives you audience, creative, and exclusion control, and it can't take credit for branded search. PMax suits ecommerce and high-volume lead gen better.

Can you run Demand Gen and Performance Max at the same time?

Yes, but they overlap on YouTube, Discover, and Gmail. Use shared exclusions, change one campaign at a time, and judge both on blended CPA and CRM pipeline.

Does Performance Max steal conversions from Search campaigns?

It can. Search wins only when the query matches an exact-match keyword. Brand variants and broader queries can go to PMax, which then reports those conversions as its own.

Which is better for YouTube ads, Demand Gen or PMax?

Demand Gen. It gives you control of video formats, audiences, and placements on YouTube. PMax uses YouTube as one channel inside a blended budget and can auto-generate video from your images.

Did Demand Gen replace Discovery campaigns?

Yes. Google upgraded Discovery campaigns to Demand Gen and later moved Video Action campaigns into it too.
Book a Call